
As you may all know by now, I am a diehard Philadelphia Phillies fan. I am a proud season ticket holder who has endured many miserable seasons with the team and now has watched my team turn into a legitimate powerhouse.
About three weeks ago, there was a buzz that the Phillies were interested in acquiring Toronto Blue Jays starting pitcher Roy Halladay. That buzz turned into serious trade negotiations that began to covered in every major sports media outlet. As a fan, I was doing back flips of joy (let that image sink into your head for a second…not pretty, huh?), but I knew that the Phils would have to give up a good deal of top prospects to make it happen. I was all-in for it because prospects are the definition of the name – a prospect not a guarantee. And you have to go for it all while your championship team window is open.
Just when it seemed to be a matter of days before Halladay would be flying into Philadelphia for a press conference after a trade to the Phillies, Toronto GM J.P. Riccardi got a little too big for his britches and decided to play hardball with not only the Phils but the rest of Halladay’s suitors as well.
Riccardi told the press that he was “holding all the cards” and that the Phillies would have to give him everything he wanted or else Halladay was going nowhere. That is a fair statement from the GM except for a few things that didn’t work in his favor. First, Halladay is only under contract through next season so if he is traded, he is only a rental. Second, Halladay has also stated that he will DEFINTIELY hit free agency when next season is over because the Blue Jays do not have the funds to secure him. Third, there are only a couple teams that have the salary luxury to afford Halladay’s current contract with a possibility for an extension. This includes the Phillies, but also the Yankees and the Red Sox can afford him as well. But the Blue Jays are in the same division as the latter teams, so that would be GM suicide for Riccardi if they ended up there. Foutth, the Phillies offered the best package of prospects (including current Phillies starter J.A. Happ) that would be really help the future of the Blue Jays. No one else compared to the level of talent the Blue Jays would receive. Fifth, Halladay has a Full No Trade Clause, which means he can reject any trade to any team, and the World Champion Phillies were pretty much the only team he would waive that right for. Lastly, if he didn’t trade Halladay this year at the deadline, offers from all suitors would drop considerably because of the decrease of Halladay’s service time before free agency – meaning that instead of having him for the rest of the season and this year’s playoffs, they’d only have him for one season only.
So what did J.P. do? He raised his demands to ridiculous proportions and decided that he was going to try and force first-year Phillies GM Ruben Amaro to yield to the media and fan pressure thus robbing the Phillies blind. J.P. says that he would not listen to offers until the July 31 deadline and then retracted that statement because deals of this magnitude cannot be squeezed into one day’s time. There was even a “leak” released to a Boston news outlet that the Red Sox offered their untouchable prospect Clay Bucholz for Halladay…which the Red Sox quickly denied. Nice try, J.P. Wonder who that “leak” worked for? Your front office, maybe?
The deadline was only a week away, so the Phillies decided to enter some serious conversations with the Cleveland Indians about starting pitcher Cliff Lee. Lee is a cheaper option, more likely to re-sign after next season and is a slightly, slightly less quality pitcher than Halladay. J.P. thought the Phillies were bluffing…
So yesterday morning, it was reported that Cleveland scouts were in Lehigh Valley to scout some of the players in a minor league game speculated to be included in a potential trade. Pitcher Carlos Carrasco was abruptly yanked before his 11 am start and I smiled. I knew it was coming. A few hours later, ESPN reported that Cliff Lee was traded to Philadelphia for prospects Carrasco, Jason Donald, Jason Knapp, and Lou Marson. The value of these players is well below the quality of prospects it would have taken to land Halladay, but Indians GM Shapiro is excellent with player evaluation so these prospects will serve him well. It was reported that Amaro called J.P. one last time with the same offer plus J.A. Happ (who is pitching lights out), but he still refused. Amaro hung up and called back the Indians to complete the deal.
On the other hand, the Phillies land a top-flight starter that will compliment the pitching staff as long as he stays healthy and keeps the ball down. His arm and finesse will be needed as the Phillies attempt to return to the playoffs for the third consecutive season.
J.P. Riccardi really shot himself in the foot with this one. He is one of the “minds” behind the Moneyball hysteria, being an assistant to A’s GM Billy Beane and was a included in a large part of that book, and this was a bad move in his part. He still must try to trade Halladay in the winter and won’t get a deal nearly as good as what the Phillies offered him. I predict that Halladay will walk next season and end up on one of the teams he avoided doing business with in the first place - the Yankees or Red Sox. If not, Riccardi will get nothing of real value in trading away a player as a one season rental. Then he will get fired as GM. That’s his problem, though. Thanks to the Indians for help in solving the Phillies with their problems and hopefully those prospects work out for his club.
Welcome to Philadelphia, Cliff Lee!!

























